No official list of the earlier fire chiefs is known to exist. However, this list has been composed from information from several sources and is believed to be the most accurate.

1876 - 1915 - No record
1916 - Herbert Clark
1917 - George Profit
1917 - T. C. Bell
1918 - 1928 - No record
1928 - 1929 - John A. Wilson
1929 - 1936 - William C. Leavitt
1936 - 1940 - Everett MacKendrick
1940 - 1942 - Wilfred Smith
1942 - 1945 - Benjamin A. Profit
1945 - 1950 - Willard R. Oulton
1950 - 1955 - John C. Profit
1955 - 1958 - Stephen M. Burke
1958 - 1959 - Perley Hardy
1959 - 1963 - Stephen M. Burke
1963 - 1980 - Herbert C. Leavitt
1980 - 1986 - Leslie C. Hardy
1986 - 1990 - William E. Gillis
1990 - 2003 - David C. Cahill
2003 - 2004 - Allan Morrison
2004 - 2009 - Paul S. Cotton
2009 - 2013 - Kenneth Ramsay
2013 - 2016 - Tom Murphy
2016 - 2018 - John Ellsworth
2018 - 2023 - Shannon Dumville
2023 - Present - Darrell Graham